| *John F. Regnault | 1867-69 | *Powhatan Wesiger | 1869-71 | |
| *John E. Laughton, Jr. | 1871-72 | *F. D. Cunningham | 1872-73 | |
| *William C. Price | 1873-75 | *Peyton Wise | 1875-76 | |
| *Howard Swineford | 1876-78 | *W. W. Stover | 1878-79 | |
| *George C. Jefferson | 1879-80 | *John N. Upshaw | 1880-81 | |
| *R.W. Bidgood | 1881-82 | *William O. English | 1882-83 | |
| *James Lyons, Jr. | 1883-85 | *John H. Powell | 1885-86 | |
| *L. T. Christian | 1886-88 | *Thomas P. Campbell | 1888-89 | |
| *Everett Waddy | 1889-91 | *Thomas S. Winn | 1891-92 | |
| *Thomas Whitlett | 1892-94 | *Samuel D. Davies | 1894-96 | |
| *Solomon Cutchins, PGM | 1896-98 | *David G. Whitehead | 1898-99 | |
| *William H. Bennett | 1899-1901 | *William D. Turner | 1901-02 | |
| *Frank T. Sutton | 1902-04 | *J. Gus Hankins | 1904-06 | |
| *Samuel H. Wilkinson | 1907 | *W. F. Richardson | 1908 | |
| *James T. Sutton | 1909-10 | *Robert S. Crump | 1911 | |
| *Clyde H. Ratcliffe | 1912 | *James A. Richardson | 1913-14 | |
| *Otis P. Walker | 1915 | *Walker D. Stuart | 1916 | |
| *Henry O. Emrick | 1917 | *Herbert L. McConnell | 1918 | |
| *L. E. Adkins | 1919 | *L. Ray Temple | 1920 | |
| *Lewis Taurman | 1921 | *Charles F. Krug | 1922 | |
| *George Wright, Jr. | 1923 | *Luke D. W. Drury | 1924 | |
| *Howell M. Baker | 1925 | *J. Neal Wright | 1926 | |
| *Guy Stulting | 1927 | *Raymond F. Stanley | 1928 | |
| *Samuel R. Sanders | 1929 | *Claude W. Woodward | 1930 | |
| *Leslie F. Johnson | 1931 | *Charles H. Fleet | 1932 | |
| *Warren K. Crump | 1933 | *C. Gilbert Miller | 1934 | |
| *Walter D. Stuart, Jr. | 1935 | *A. Bernard Cosby | 1936 | |
| *Joseph F. White | 1937 | *Robert B. Gayle | 1938 | |
| *R. B. Wright | 1939 | *A. Sydney Johnson | 1940 | |
| *Alvey E. Bartholomew | 1941 | *Lawrence F. Worrell | 1942 | |
| *Joseph F. White, Jr. | 1943 | *T. Herbert Vaughn | 1944 | |
| *Eric L. Watkins | 1945 | *George R. Sydnor | 1946 | |
| *William W. Dunn | 1947 | *Charles W. Paganelli | 1948 | |
| *N. Edward Whitlow | 1949 | *Carl C. Battage | 1950 | |
| *Murray A. Harrison | 1951 | William A. Bowers | 1952 | |
| *Raymond J. Frank | 1953 | *Roland W. Taylor | 1954 | |
| *William M. Chandler | 1955 | Charles G. Miller, Jr. | 1956 | |
| Wesley Wayne Utley | 1957 | *Emmett W. Farley, Jr. | 1958 | |
| *Roy W. Davis | 1959 | *John C. Goode, Jr. | 1960 | |
| Edward A. Strange | 1961 | Carl W. Smelley | 1962 | |
| John B. Russell | 1963 | *Patrick H. Woodward | 1964 | |
| David V. Chapman, Jr. | 1965 | William W. Bell | 1966 | |
| *Charles W. Ball | 1967 | *Alvin B. Andrews | 1968 | |
| *Owen H. Friedhoff | 1969 | *John F. Irving | 1970 | |
| Denys Grant | 1971 | Frank W. Lambert, Jr. | 1972 | |
| *Willie P. Ligon | 1973 | *John L. Barlow | 1974 | |
| E. Milton Skelton, PDDGM | 1975 | John J. Hall, PDDGM | 1976 | |
| William P. Rickard III | 1977 | Larry E. Thornton | 1978 | |
| > | 1979 | *Robert M. Shepherd, PDDGM | 1980 | |
| Bradford F. Burnett, PDDGM | 1981 | Frank A. McDonald, Jr. | 1982 | |
| Robert M. Spencer | 1983 | *William Malone Harris | 1984 | |
| Thomas C. Smith | 1985 | Ray D. Shores | 1986 | |
| *James D. Crockett | 1987 | *Jean K. Walton | 1988 | |
| Gary R. Eck | 1989 | Ernest W. Ross, PDDGM | 1990 | |
| Grady A. Griner | 1991 | *William M. Cottrell | 1992 | |
| *William R. East | 1993 | Ernest W. Ross, PDDGM | 1994 | |
| Richard L. Dennis | 1995 | Randy J. Kangas | 1996 | |
| Wayne T. Geisel | 1997 | Johnny W. Inman | 1998 | |
| *Earl J. Green | 1999 | Gerald W. Eagle | 2000 | |
| Timothy H. Winstead | 2001 | Gerald W. Eagle | 2002 | |
| James W. White | 2003 | Raymond D. Tyus | 2004 | |
| James W. White | 2005 | James W. White | 2006 | |
| Michael D. Joyner | 2007 | Stephen D. Beverly | 2008 | |
| David P. Clifton, Jr. | 2009 | |||